Concern about recent comments from the Home Office and the unfair targeting of the sacred Sikh Kirpan Message your MP now
Dear MP
I am writing as your constituent to express my deep concern about recent comments from the Home Office and the unfair targeting of the sacred Sikh Kirpan.
Like many others, I fully support Henry Nowak’s family in their call for answers, accountability and action to ensure that no other family suffers such a terrible loss. However, it is deeply troubling that the Home Office appears to be using this case to focus on the Kirpan in a way that is inaccurate, disproportionate and harmful to the Sikh community.
The murder weapon used in Henry Nowak’s killing was not the sacred Kirpan. Hampshire Police and the Crown Prosecution Service acknowledged this immediately after sentencing on 1 June 2026 when they released a photograph of the murder weapon. It is therefore alarming that the Home Office continues to engage publicly on the basis of a misleading narrative.
The Home Office has stated that it has been discussing the religious reasons defence with Sikh stakeholders. However, many law-abiding Sikhs, including myself, are unaware of who these stakeholders are, and what if any, public engagement they have undertaken with the Sikh community over five months since the Vikrum Digwa’s trial.
I am particularly concerned that leading Sikh organisations, which have for over two decades advised government and public bodies on the Kirpan and are regularly quoted in the media, do not appear to have been consulted. Likewise, I am not aware of any meaningful engagement with Gurdwaras or with the UK Gurdwara Alliance, despite their role in representing Sikh congregations and understanding the practical and religious significance of the Kirpan.
For discussions on such a sensitive matter to be credible, they must include Sikh organisations and Gurdwaras with a genuine understanding of the faith and broad confidence within the Sikh community. It is also essential that any consultation process is transparent and free from perceived conflicts of interest.
I understand some Sikh stakeholders are or may be conflicted e.g. Sikh police officers or personal friends of the CPS expert witness who gave evidence in the Digwa case. In addition, I understand several Sikh academics may have been invited as stakeholders who are not fully practising Sikhs who by definition will not fully appreciate the religious defence.
The Home Secretary’s statement in Parliament in June drew a distinction between carrying the sacred Kirpan for religious observance and using a blade to harm someone. I am therefore concerned by the Home Secretary’s recent public comments, which seemed to blur the important distinction between the sacred Kirpan carried for religious observance and a weapon used to cause harm. This has caused distress to many Sikhs and suggests that engagement with the Sikh community is seriously lacking.
It is deeply upsetting for law abiding Sikhs to see a central part of our faith being discussed and questioned by the Home Secretary in a media interview ignoring the murder weapon was not the sacred Kirpan. There is huge scepticism that this is a deflection tactic as the police, IOPC and other law enforcement agencies failed Henry and his family.
The Sikh community, like all communities, supports efforts to tackle knife crime. However, the current direction of travel from the Home Office appears both irresponsible and disproportionate.
I would be grateful if you could write to the Home Secretary on my behalf and ask her to: - Provide the names of the Gurdwaras and Sikh organisations the Home Office has met to discuss the religious reasons defence, and explain how they were selected as opposed to others - Explain what safeguards were in place to manage any potential ethical conflicts of interest among those consulted i.e. Sikh police officers and personal friends of the CPS expert witness in the Digwa case - Clarify what proportion of Sikh academics consulted are fully practising Sikhs - Commit to meeting leading Sikh organisations with long-standing experience of advising government and public bodies on the Kirpan, as well as the UK Gurdwara Alliance - Clarify the basis on which the Home Secretary is considering changes to legislation relating to the religious reasons defence for the Kirpan, given that the murder weapon used in Henry Nowak’s case was not a Kirpan
I would also be grateful if you could share your letter to the Home Secretary and any response received.
Thank you for your time and attention to this important issue.
Please add your name and address__
